2025/8/7 9:42:13 阅读:208 发布者:
01
投稿前的细节检查
魔鬼藏在细节中
(一)标题与摘要:论文的"门面"工程
论文的标题和摘要是编辑和审稿人首先看到的内容,直接决定了他们是否愿意继续阅读全文。
1、标题:
需准确反映研究主题,避免过长或过短。检查标题是否包含关键术语,同时避免使用缩写。
2、运行标题(Running Title):
通常为标题的简写版本,需符合期刊要求。
3、摘要:
需包含研究背景、科学问题、假说、方法、结果和结论。
4、特别注意:
是否首次使用缩写时提供了全称?
方法与结果的描述顺序是否一致?
字数是否控制在300词以内?
5、实用技巧:
写完摘要后,尝试用摘要中的关键词在数据库中进行检索,看看是否能准确找到类似研究,这是检验摘要质量的一个好方法。
(二) 作者信息与伦理声明
许多投稿因作者信息不全或伦理声明缺失而被直接拒稿:
1、作者列表:
确认所有贡献者都被列入,姓名拼写准确无误。特别检查通讯作者的详细信息(单位、地址、邮箱、电话)。
2、伦理声明:
尤其是涉及动物实验或人体研究时,必须包含伦理审查批准信息。
3、利益冲突声明:
所有潜在利益冲突都必须公开。
4、常见错误:
通讯作者邮箱使用毕业院校邮箱(.edu)而该邮箱即将失效,导致后续沟通中断。
(三)论文主体
从Introduction到Discussion的完整闭环
1、Introduction写作要点:
第一段:提供充分但不过度的背景知识
第二段:明确指出研究空白和科学问题
第三段:提出假说并概述研究内容
2、检查重点:是否所有缩写首次出现时都提供了全称?逻辑是否层层递进?
3、Methods部分:
实验材料和试剂信息是否完整(厂商、批号等)?
每个实验是否以目的陈述开头?
统计分析方法是否详细说明?
常见问题:方法描述过于简略,导致其他研究者无法重复实验。
4、Results部分:
是否采用"结果-数据-分析"的三段式结构?
文字描述与图表信息是否一致?
显著性差异是否明确标注?
5、Discussion部分:
第一段是否重述主要发现?
是否充分讨论与同行研究的异同?
是否承认研究局限性?
最后一段是否为总结性陈述?
(四)图表与参考文献:专业性的体现
1、图表检查清单:
分辨率是否足够(通常要求300dpi以上)?
是否为CMYK色彩模式(针对印刷期刊)?
坐标轴标签、单位是否完整?
三线表格格式是否正确?
图例信息是否完整?
2、参考文献常见问题:
格式不统一(尤其注意作者姓名、期刊名缩写等)
引用数量不足或过多
漏引关键文献或过多引用自己团队工作
(五)格式与投稿前最后检查
1、检查
确认各部分是否单独成页
检查页码和行号
字体、字号、行距是否符合期刊要求
2、查重:
完成查重(通常要求低于15-20%)
进行英文母语润色(尤其对非英语母语作者)
3、特别提醒:
投稿前确保所有作者都阅读并认可最终版本,确认每位作者的邮箱都是常用邮箱。
实用工具
02
投稿信写作技巧与实用句型
附模板
01
标准投稿信模板
Dear Dr. [编辑姓名],
Please find enclosed our manuscript entitled "[论文标题]" by [作者列表], which we are submitting for publication in [期刊名称]. We have chosen this journal because [简要说明与期刊范围的契合点].
The main findings of this study are: [3-4句概括核心发现及其意义]. We believe this work would be of particular interest to the readers of your journal because [说明对期刊读者的价值].
All authors have read and approved this version of the article. We confirm that this work is original and has not been published elsewhere, nor is it currently under consideration for publication in another journal. [如有需要,可添加利益冲突声明或特别说明].
Thank you for considering our manuscript. We look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely yours,
[通讯作者姓名]
[详细联系方式]
02
投稿信实用句型库
1、强调原创性:
"The authors claim that none of the material in the paper has been published or is under consideration for publication elsewhere."
2、说明期刊选择理由:
"We have chosen this journal because it deals with [领域], and we believe our findings on [具体内容] would be of interest to the journal's readers."
3、声明伦理合规:
"Due care has been taken to ensure the integrity of the work. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of [机构名称] (Approval No. XXX)."
03
投稿后跟进邮件
1、确认稿件收到:
Dear Editors,
We dispatched our manuscript titled "[标题]" (Manuscript ID: XXX) to your journal on [日期] but have not yet received acknowledgement of receipt. We would be grateful if you could confirm whether the manuscript has been received safely.
Thank you for your assistance.
Best regards,
[姓名]
2、询问审稿进度:
Dear Editors,
It has been [周数] weeks since I submitted our manuscript (ID: XXX) for possible publication in your journal. I have not yet received a decision and would appreciate it if you could update me on the current status of the review process.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
[姓名]
03
审稿意见回应策略与实用句型
专业回应技巧:
审稿意见类型及应对策略
1、正面意见:
"This is a carefully done study and the findings are of considerable interest."
回应策略:表示感谢,确认已按要求修改
2、需小修的意见:
"A few minor revisions are listed below."
回应策略:逐条回复,说明修改位置
3、需大修的意见:
"Although these observations are interesting, they are rather limited..."
回应策略:认真对待,补充实验或数据
4、拒稿意见:
"This manuscript is not suitable for publication in the journal of - because..."
回应策略:评估意见合理性,考虑改投或补充工作
回应审稿意见的实用句型
1、通用开头:
"We thank the reviewers for their insightful comments, which have helped us improve the manuscript. Below we provide a point-by-point response to the reviewers' concerns. All changes in the manuscript are highlighted in red for easy identification."
2、针对具体意见的回应方式:
(1)接受意见并修改:
"As suggested by the reviewer, we have [具体修改内容]. This change can be found in [修改位置]."
(2)接受意见但修改方式不同:
"We agree with the reviewer that [意见核心]. However, instead of [审稿人建议], we have [作者采取的方案] because [理由]. Please see [修改位置]."
(3)礼貌性保留不同意见:
"We appreciate the reviewer's concern regarding [问题]. However, we prefer to retain [原有内容] because [科学理由]. We have added [说明文字] to clarify this point in [位置]."
(4)补充实验后的回应:
"In response to the reviewer's comment, we have completed additional experiments as suggested. The results (now included as [新图表]) confirm our original findings and provide further support for [结论]."
(5)语言问题的回应:
"We apologize for the language issues and have thoroughly revised the manuscript with the assistance of a native English speaker."
修改稿投稿信模板
Dear Dr. [编辑姓名],
Thank you for your letter of [日期] and the reviewers' comments concerning our manuscript entitled "[标题]" (MS ID: XXX). We have carefully considered all the comments and made corresponding revisions to improve the manuscript.
In particular:
1. [简要概括主要修改内容]
2. [说明是否补充实验]
3. [其他重要修改]
We believe the revised manuscript has been significantly improved and now fully addresses the reviewers' concerns. All changes are highlighted in red in the manuscript for easy identification.
We appreciate the opportunity to revise our work and hope the revised version is now suitable for publication in [期刊名称]. Please do not hesitate to contact us if further information is required.
Sincerely yours,
[通讯作者]
转自Uni学术智圈微信公众号,仅作学习交流,如有侵权,请联系本站删除!